Roll Call: Latest News on Capitol Hill, Congress, Politics and Elections
February 9, 2016

Conservatives Regroup to Force Leadership to Change

Labrador worked the phones but came up short. (Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call)

Labrador worked the phones but came up short. (Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call)

They may have lost their fight to change leadership, but they intend to force leadership to change.

Conservatives who backed Raúl R. Labrador’s bid for majority leader are saying they are already on to the next battle to force change from within the House Republican Conference.

Austin Scott, R-Ga., who was one of Labrador’s earliest supporters, told CQ Roll Call that like-minded lawmakers are “extremely likely” to pursue an effort to address how the House operates.

“A lot of us, not just conservatives, are going to press to rewrite the rules of the House,” Scott said.

Specifically, Scott mentioned frustration regarding the three-day rule, which is supposed to give members at least three days time between when a bill is posted and when it comes up for a vote. In practice, House leaders could post a bill at 11:59 p.m. on a Tuesday and vote on it at 12:01 a.m. on a Thursday, which is why Scott called it, “technically, the 24-hours and two-minutes” rule.

Labrador found some traction in his message of abiding by the three-day rule, allowing more votes on amendments, giving more power to the committees and members and taking power away from leadership staffers.

The winner of the race, current Whip Kevin McCarthy of California, seemed to glom onto that message, adopting much of Labrador’s platform in his candidates’ forum speech ahead of the closed-door vote.

Whether McCarthy can actually make those changes before he faces another leadership challenge remains to be seen. He’ll be majority leader for 15 days before the next leadership elections are held on Nov. 17.

And Labrador, who finds himself at a congressional crossroads, could lead a pressure campaign for McCarthy and the rest of the leadership team to solidify those promises.

“I think he’s got an important role to play in this conference,” Justin Amash recently said of Labrador.

“He represents the next generation of Republicans,” the Michigan Republican said, pointing to Labrador’s positions on civil liberties and “corporate welfare.”

Can these sorts of Republicans with their notorious independent streaks ever coalesce behind one leader? Amash seemed to think they could — whether it be Labrador, or Jeb Hensarling, or even himself, the chairman of the Liberty Caucus. “I think we’ve got some great candidates, and I hope Raúl takes another shot at it,” Amash said.

Labrador told reporters recently he views his failed bid as “a building block for something to come.” But, the Idaho Republican cautioned, “I don’t — I can’t tell you what that something to come is.”

He says his “next mission” is to sit down with every member of the GOP conference to discuss the race and the party’s direction. “You can be a leader without being in leadership,” he said.

After Labrador lost the race, he sent around a “Dear Colleague” letter thanking members — even those who voted for McCarthy, who he thanked for their consideration.

“Every member agrees that we can do better; that we must do better. The process needs to be improved, the committees need to work their will, and our members need to feel more relevant,” he wrote in the letter.

Will Labrador try again? He says he doesn’t know, and that come November he will “reassess” with his wife and his family.

But, he said, “If I think that there’s a vacuum, and it needs to be filled, I’m not going to be asking anybody else to fill that vacuum.”


Related stories:

Sprint to Power: 10 Days Inside the GOP Leadership Race

Would-Be Whips Woo Conservatives, Reassure Moderates 

2010 Class Plots Comeback Strategy in Late-Night Meeting

Labrador Appeals Directly to Colleagues for Support in Majority Leader Race 

Roskam-Scalise Whip Race Heats Up, Gets Ugly

Stutzman Enters Whip Race, Complicating Scalise Chances

FreedomWorks Wants Labrador for Majority Leader

Is Boehner’s Gavel on the Line?

Stunner: Cantor Loss Changes Everything

Get breaking news alerts and more from Roll Call in your inbox or on your iPhone.

  • ShadrachSmith

    The Tea Party is the Madisonian small-government wing of American politics. American politics has had a small-government wing ever since…Madison.

    Obama’s use/misuse of government power has convinced a lot more people to listen to the small-government arguments. It is only natural that the small-government, classical-liberal wing of American politics should be gaining power, stature, and votes. Obama did that.


    The Republican & Democratic parties both have failed the three million unemployed workers without an extension bill since late last December. These families have fallen deeper into financial ruin and deep poverty, over the past six months, waiting for the senate to pass the extension bill. While billions of tax payer dollars have been approves for the Ukraine, and the defense of Europe, no action has been taken to pass the extension bill in the senate. The republicans spent more energy and focus on getting the Koch brothers oil pipeline passed, then they did with any other bill to help average Americans in need. They have proven themselves to be a party lacking in both compassion, and common decency. These millions of families have lost everything while waiting for the government to help them,

  • Bob Stauskas

    The liberty school recognizes the dangers to liberty posed by collectivists who seize upon temporary crises to centralize government power.

  • Michael Ramirez

    While those who understand freedom recognize that democratic methods tend to be aligned with liberty, those obsessed with their own selfish interests realize that democratic methods are susceptible to hijacking.

  • Ized Fohssil

    Arguably, the regard for responsibility has fallen low enough to undermine the very freedom upon which our prosperity and civilization rest.

  • Yonatan YONATAN

    It’s been six months without an unemployment extension bill for the three million unemployed families still without benefits. The republicans senate has made every effort to delay the vote to render it too late for passing. This was done in a very calculated manner, without compassion or common decency towards these struggling families. The republican senate has destined these families to financial ruin and utter poverty. They have walked away from the issue, leaving these families without an income source. However, they fought tooth and nail for the Koch Brother’s Oil Pipeline bill to be passed. They have demonstrated for whom they work for, and it’s not the average American, living paycheck to paycheck. The republicans are working for corporate America and special interest groups with deep pockets. The congress recently passed a foreign aid package for the Ukraine. worth Billions of tax payer dollars, but failed helping these poor families in need.


      If KeystoneXL had been approved, there would have been many jobs available for the unemployed. Or do you not want to work? There are also many jobs still available in Williston, ND! My son works there, but, his family lives in LA. He gets to see them every other month, but it pays the bills for the most part. He also has been ruined (credit), he lost one of their vehicles. But, has never relied on unemployment. There is work available, if you really want to work. You don’t have to live there, but you can and have much better hours, if you can find a place to live. There are also construction jobs in the warmer months. Many opportunities also available in South and West Texas. Just look!

  • Albert Leviation

    While David Hume noted that the rules of our morality are not the conclusions of our reason, those who oppose liberty tend to assert that our morals, customs, and traditions have been consciously designed.

  • Softie

    Those things which become available to most of us only become so because they were first the luxury of a few who could afford to try them.

Sign In

Forgot password?



Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...