Roll Call: Latest News on Capitol Hill, Congress, Politics and Elections
February 10, 2016

‘Doc Fix’ Deal Passes Without Roll Call Vote (Updated) (Video)

(Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call)

(Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call File Photo)

Updated March 27, 12:49 a.m. | The House passed controversial “doc fix” legislation with a voice vote Thursday, after House GOP leaders spent hours scrambling to round up votes for the deal backed by Speaker John A. Boehner and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.

The power move bypassed a recorded roll call vote, with the votes remaining in doubt, incensing some members of the House. Asked if she went along with the voice vote plan, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., simply said “yes.”

Without a roll call vote, it’s impossible to know exactly who would have voted for or against the measure, or if it would have had the two-thirds needed to pass on the suspension calendar.

The House had recessed unexpectedly Thursday morning as GOP leaders sought to round up the votes needed to pass the measure ensuring Medicare payments to doctors aren’t cut.

“It’s looking very good,” House Majority Leader Eric Cantor said earlier. “We’re working on it.”

Immediately after GOP aides told CQ Roll Call the bill would be pulled Thursday morning for a lack of votes, the House Republican Doctors Caucus, which had been opposed to the measure, huddled in a room off of the House floor and were soon joined by GOP leaders. Staff was kicked out of the room.

House Minority Whip Steny H. Hoyer, D-Md., told CQ Roll Call he would oppose the bill but would not whip against it, while Pelosi earlier told reporters she would vote for the bill if it came to a vote and said Reid told her he wants it to pass.

Many Democrats would be voting “no,” she said, including two committee ranking members: Henry A. Waxman of Energy and Commerce, and Sander M. Levin of Ways and Means.

“This is the wrong way to go,” she said. “However, you know as well as I, if this does not pass … seniors may be turned away from their physicians, and you know what Republicans will say: It was because of the Affordable Care Act. They won’t even say it that way, but that’s their point. And I just don’t want to give them another — the bill in itself, I don’t like it, but it serves a purpose.”

Pelosi also said on Thursday morning that she wasn’t sure how the vote would go down, but suspected that Republicans didn’t have the votes.

“I don’t know why they didn’t just bring it up under the rule, had the discussion, take the vote, but to bring it up under suspension where you have 290 votes or the equivalent of two-thirds of those present and voting, is a mystery to me, unless they thought they couldn’t get 218 votes on their side,” she said.

The Doctors Caucus and Senate Finance Chairman Ron Wyden, D-Ore., had been pushing back against the deal Boehner announced Wednesday.

The Ohio Republican told reporters Wednesday morning that he and Reid had struck a deal on a yearlong policy that would avoid drastic cuts to Medicare payments to physicians.

Yet soon after, the Nevada Democrat said the deal was merely a work in progress. Wyden piled on, saying he does not support a short-term fix. And on Wednesday afternoon, key House Republicans concerned with health policy said they will most likely not support Boehner’s legislation.

Members of the Doctors Caucus, a group of physicians in the GOP, said the policy would allow Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to revalue Medicare physician payments arbitrarily to pay for the policy, which they see as a broad expansion of executive power that could hit medical specialists’s pocketbooks.

Rep. Phil Roe, R-Tenn., a member of the caucus, crafted a letter he may send to Boehner on the matter. He noted that the group is also unhappy that the legislation was unveiled late Tuesday, giving the conference little time to absorb the specifics.

Rep. John Fleming, R-La., another member of the caucus, said Wednesday night he did not think the bill had enough votes to pass.

“They haven’t whipped us on it, so I’m not sure what their thinking is. I don’t think it’s right for passage,” he said. “Our caucus tends to go by what doctors recommend. So I’m not so sure our caucus, the non-physicians, are going to back something that the doctors are not going to. There’s a lot in flux until tomorrow.”

  • Debby Ward

    get rid of welfare and medicaid, NOT what the hard working tax payers earned when their money went into SS and Medicare..

    • Raylusk

      You forget that the amount those hard working tax payers put into Social Security and Medicare doesn’t even come close to covering the Federal Governments cost of providing those services. But there are ways to fix this with out taking it out on the poor which is what you proposed. How about returning to the effective tax rates that the wealthy paid after Reagan’s first tax cut? That would provide plenty of revenue.

  • Diogenesxxx

    Did Senator Rockefeller infer it or did he imply it?

  • Six Edits

    While collectivism and altruism are often considered synonymous, it is egoism that opposes altruism & individualism that opposes collectivism.

  • Doug Watson

    Does ANYONE really believe John Boehner as ANY clout at all with his fellow House Republicans? He’s the Speaker in name only with little else!

  • Gyst53

    It would be interesting to see if a Barber’s haircuts were paid for by the Government how much the haircut would cost!

    We don’t want the Docs’s to go destitute now would we?
    The physician salary survey below allows you to identify trends in physician salaries and compensation across numerous specialties.


    National 6 yrs Practicing Average

    Allergy & Immunology
    Cardiac & Thoracic Surgery
    Colon & Rectal Surgery
    Critical Care Medicine
    Diagnostic Radiology – Interventional
    Diagnostic Radiology – Non-Interventional
    Family Medicine
    Family Medicine – with Obstetrics
    General Surgery
    Gynecological Oncology
    Gynecology & Obstetrics
    Hematology & Medical Oncology
    Infectious Disease
    Internal Medicine
    Neurological Surgery
    Orthopedic Surgery
    Orthopedic Surgery – Pediatrics
    Orthopedic Surgery – Spine
    Pediatric Cardiology
    Pediatric Endocrinology
    Pediatric Gastroenterology
    Pediatric Hematology / Oncology
    Pediatric Infectious Disease
    Pediatric Intensive Care
    Pediatric Nephrology
    Pediatric Neurology
    Pediatric Pulmonary Disease
    Pediatric Surgery
    Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
    Plastic Surgery
    Psychiatry – Child
    Pulmonary Disease
    Trauma Surgery
    Urgent Care
    Vascular Surgery
    This Physician Salary Survey is based on 2011-12 nationwide, confidential survey of over 80,000 practicing physicians.

    • crusader2010

      Now add in Medical school costs. and see what you get. fees, licenses and malpractice insurance also.

Sign In

Forgot password?



Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...