Roll Call: Latest News on Capitol Hill, Congress, Politics and Elections
October 8, 2015

Gay Immigrants Pose Thorny Test for ‘Gang of 8′

“Gang of eight” immigration negotiators purposely didn’t include provisions for immigrants in same-sex relationships in their bipartisan bill, but the issue they so carefully avoided may rear its head this week.

As the Senate Judiciary Committee prepares for its Thursday markup of the group’s comprehensive immigration bill, it remains unclear whether Chairman Patrick J. Leahy will offer an amendment to allow same-sex partners of American citizens and permanent residents to gain legal status.

Whether Leahy decides to offer it in committee or on the floor matters because the provision has a much better shot of adoption if offered during the markup than it does during full Senate debate.

Republican “gang of eight” Sens. Jeff Flake of Arizona and Marco Rubio of Florida have told multiple media outlets that including the provision, known as the Uniting American Families Act, could be the kind of deal-breaker that would take down the bill. But Leahy dismissed that notion Sunday on “Meet the Press.”

“We’ve had about 10 different things that people say will kill it. If we don’t make the fence long enough, that kills it. If we don’t have a high enough fine, that kills it.  The fact is there are a lot of people who want to kill an immigration bill no matter what,” the Vermont Democrat said. “We will have votes on this. People can vote for or against any one of these amendments.”

Asked about the issue last week during an appearance on Hugh Hewitt’s radio show, Rubio didn’t mince words, as David M. Drucker noted on the Goppers blog. During the interview, Rubio said:

“It was not intended to cover everybody in every situation. We acknowledged from the beginning that there are people that will not be able to take advantage of the bill. It’s not a blanket bill that covers every immigration scenario. Second, this immigration bill is difficult enough as it is. There are already enough questions being asked, questions that need to be answered, legitimate points that are being raised. If you inject something like this in the bill, it will die. The coalition behind it will fall apart, and it will make it, that will not pass. It’s just that simple. If that issue is injected into this bill, this bill will fail. It will not pass, it will not have the support, it will not have my support, and so I hope we can avoid this.”

Leahy has not said for sure that he will offer the amendment in committee, though there may be some sense of that early in the week, because the Judiciary panel is requiring that all amendments be filed by 5 p.m. Tuesday.

Democratic Sens. Charles E. Schumer of New York and Richard J. Durbin of Illinois would be hard-pressed to vote against the language in the Judiciary Committee, given their support for expanded gay rights and their home-state constituencies. But as members of the bipartisan group that negotiated the bill, they have an informal agreement to vote against contentious provisions that could paralyze the debate.

“If we feel the bill can be improved by various amendments, we will support those amendments,” Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., explained April 25. “But if it’s an amendment that is designed to kill the bill, as happened in 2007, we will probably together defend the bill from going down.”

The amendment to allow gay couples with one foreign partner to gain residency or citizenship for the second partner the same way heterosexual married couples do could be the first test. On this question, it seems likely that Schumer and Durbin would side with Leahy if asked to cast a vote. Without Durbin’s and Schumer’s support, the provision would almost certainly fail in committee, and the political fallout could be potentially ugly for them.

However, if Leahy just waited until floor consideration, Durbin and Schumer might be spared the trouble. Offering the amendment on the Senate floor would require a more dramatic uphill climb, because opponents would be all but certain to require a 60-vote supermajority for adoption. So, Durbin’s and Schumer’s votes for the amendment would be unlikely to push it over the top, and its failure would ensure their underlying agreement with Republicans in the group would remain intact.

But Leahy may not be swayed to help out the duo. His contention that the language regarding gay couples wouldn’t sink the bill seems to be based in part on the past example of his Violence Against Women Act re-authorization.

That bill eventually became law, but not until after intense wrangling in the House that included debate over provisions regarding same-sex relationships and protections on tribal lands. On that House vote, 87 Republicans joined with Democrats to send the final measure to President Barack Obama’s desk. In that case, moderate Republicans in both chambers demonstrated that they would vote for expanded protections for the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community.

Comments (15)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

author email

  1. arjayt

    May 7, 2013
    8:04 a.m.

    Niels Lesniewski, Rollcall: “That bill eventually became law, but not until after intense wrangling in the House that included debate over provisions regarding same-sex relationships and protections on tribal lands. On that House vote, 87 Republicans joined with Democrats to send the final measure to President Barack Obama’s desk. In that case, moderate Republicans in both chambers demonstrated that they would vote for expanded protections for the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community.”

    This process could go on forever. Violence Against Women is usually carried out by males who have a primitive ‘control’ DNA code built into them where they instinctively require a ‘slave’ that can gratify their fantasies. Normal males and females don’t have such pronounced DNA sequences, anymore than they have the inherited LGBT sequences involving an altered hypothalamus/amygdala process. There are DNA sequences creating sociopathic aggression, cancer, 800 separate mental anomalies and hundreds of sequences involved in molecular distortions of body parts such as Downs Syndrome.

    Must the Congress create legislation to give special protection and/or privilege (such cannot be human rights) to each specific molecular structure defined by the Human Genome? How about special laws giving protections such as the Tudor, Hapsburg, Romanov and Ming families enjoyed to ANY American family who feels it’s status is threatened by taxation? How about special laws protecting violent individuals in communities because they can’t help what they do? Ad infinitum?

  2. Badan

    July 24, 2015
    8:26 a.m. is a great place for adult contacts check out for british escort directory adult connections is the best company for escort contacts. Please visit site:

  3. Badan

    July 25, 2015
    5:24 a.m.

    Hi, my name is Ian I am a straight male escort looking to provide and share good conversation, but most importantly, a fun time together and to meet new people. I am very easy going and I can guarantee no awkwardness. I love making people smile as I think that is the best gift you can give someone :-) . Please click here site

  4. Badan

    July 25, 2015
    5:42 a.m.

    Your one stop adult sex shop, from adult toys to free porn videos to booking your ultimate sex holiday! Awesome HD porn movies amd much more! Please visit web

  5. Badan

    July 25, 2015
    6:01 a.m.

    Thane Call Girl Rs @ 3500 Girl in Thane Call 08452907412 . It is pure relaxation, breathing body and soul. Thane Outcalls escorts that provide Massage are carefully selected according to which relaxation techniques and massage, education, beauty and ability they possess. You can easily find a charming Sydney escort that can offer you a wonderful experience full of joy, passion, relaxation and excitement. for More info :

  6. Badan

    July 26, 2015
    8:06 a.m.

    Teens having hot sex. For more info, Please visit my web url:

  7. Badan

    July 26, 2015
    8:08 a.m.

    The most beautiful girls in the world are nude in pictures and videos. For more information, please visit my site

  8. Badan

    Aug. 6, 2015
    5:33 a.m.

    Welcome to – The UK’s Brightest Holiday Comparison Website! 44holidays is a holiday comparison website with live travel comparison searches that makes finding your next holiday easy. Whether you’re looking for an all-inclusive holiday or if you’re searching for last minute holiday deals and holiday bargains, 44holidays is the only holiday comparison you need! With millions of holiday offers available at any time, including package holidays, skiing holidays, cruises and city breaks, 44holidays is one of the largest travel comparison websites in the UK. From weekends away to city breaks to holidays abroad, 44holidays is your complete travel partner. 44holidays – Where holidays are made! For more info visit at

  9. Badan

    Aug. 11, 2015
    10:51 a.m.

    The Best Way To Fight Male Pattern Baldness Now And In The Future! Male pattern baldness (MPB), scientifically known as Androgenetic Alopecia, affects 70 percent of men before they reach age 70. MPB is associated with a genetic predisposition to dihydrotestosterone (DHT) sensitivity. DHT is a derivative of testosterone and in prone men, it destroys hair follicles along the mid-anterior scalp and temples. Please visit

  10. Badan

    Aug. 17, 2015
    11:21 a.m.

  11. Badan

    Sept. 20, 2015
    8:02 a.m.

    PornGeek is the best websites for FREE HD porn videos. Watch and download movies without signing in. FREE HD Porn from Geeks for Geeks. visit

  12. Badan

    Sept. 20, 2015
    8:04 a.m.

    Escorts Club o seu site de Acompanhantes e garotas de programa de Brasilia As mais belas Acompanhantes de Luxo do DF. Sinta-se à vontade! Por favor, visite o site

  13. Badan

    Oct. 6, 2015
    12:49 a.m.

    High quality free porn videos in hard sex tube gallery are ready to make you melt down from streaming hot sex movies! And other info, visit my site :)

  14. Badan

    Oct. 7, 2015
    2:53 p.m.

    Melayani Jasa Pembuatan Website Toko Online, serta tips dan trik cara membuat website toko online dengan mudah dan cepat. Silakan kunjungi website

  15. Badan

    Oct. 7, 2015
    3:01 p.m. adalah situs agen judi poker domino qq online,capsa susun online yang sangat terpercaya di indonesia, berkecepatan server tinggi dan di jamin aman. Silahkan kunjungi

Sign In

Forgot password?



Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...