Roll Call: Latest News on Capitol Hill, Congress, Politics and Elections
September 2, 2015

Recess Appointment Debate Unlikely to End at Supreme Court

(Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call)

(Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call)

Even a Supreme Court opinion throwing out President Barack Obama’s recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board wouldn’t end the debate.

Justices from across the ideological spectrum seemed to have doubts during oral arguments Monday about the administration’s arguments, with the president’s power to get around Senate roadblocks to name his own team at stake.

The administration argued that the recess appointments were valid because the Senate’s practice of holding pro forma sessions every three days without conducting business was no different than being out of town.

An exchange between Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. and Justice Elena Kagan put the argument into relief.

Kagan asked Verrilli if the Senate could convene for unanimous consent requests to name post offices and conduct “trivial business” to avoid the argument over the pro forma sessions.

“I think if they did business each of the three days, then you wouldn’t have a situation in which no business was conducted and you wouldn’t meet the definition of a recess, but that’s a different case than this one,” Verrilli said.

Kagan replied that if the rule defining what constitutes a recess would be “so easy to evade, [it] suggests that this really is — the question of how to define a recess really does belong to the Senate.”

“I think the problem with looking at it that way, Justice Kagan, is that that’s the end of the recess appointment power,” Verrilli said. “You write it out of the Constitution, if you look at it that way, because all the Senate needs to do is stay in pro forma session until 11:59 a.m. on January 3rd when that term ends and the next term starts and then there are no intercession recesses.”

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg seemed to share Kagan’s thinking.

“The Senate, I think to be candid, the Senate is always available. They can be called back on very short notice. So what is it that’s the constitutional flaw here?” Ginsburg said, questioning Verrilli. “It isn’t … that the Senate isn’t available. The Senate is available. It can easily be convened.”

Even if the Supreme Court decides it is within the Senate’s power to determine when it is in session, the president might still have a way to force through recess appointments. That would rely, however, on an untested constitutional provision that would appear to allow a president to force Congress to go home.

None other than Miguel Estrada, appearing as counsel representing the interests of Senate Republicans during the unusually long oral argument session Monday, raised that possibility. Estrada’s own nomination to the federal appellate bench was famously upended by opposition from Democrats.

“If the Senate had any view that it wanted to recess, they could have had a vote, and the issue would have ended up in the White House, in the lap of the president,” Estrada said. “He had plenary constitutional power to give himself an intersession recess by terminating the session and have a real recess appointment power if he could find somebody whose vacancy had actually arisen at the time.”

The same section of the Constitution that provides for the president to update Congress on the state of the union and to recall Congress into session to attend to urgent business also allows for forced adjournment when the two chambers fail to reach consensus on adjourning.

“In Case of Disagreement between them, with Respect to the Time of Adjournment, he may adjourn them to such Time as he shall think proper,” the Constitution states in part of Article II, Section III. Estrada wasn’t backing such a maneuver, but he certainly suggested it was a possibility.

A senior Senate Democratic aide said “it would be unlikely that Democrats would need to go down that road, given” that they have sought to ease the nominations process by lowering the threshold for overcoming a filibuster.

“This is the cockeyed way of going about the instruments of the Constitution. There is no power in the Constitution to use the Recess Appointments Clause to overcome the opposition of the Senate to the president’s nominees. And for all that we hear about today, which has to do with how the heaven will fall, and the parade of horribles, there is no parade, and there is no horrible,” Estrada argued.

Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky was one of several GOP senators in the chamber for the oral arguments.

“The Court today was rightly skeptical of the Solicitor General’s inconsistent argument that the Senate is in session if the President wants it to pass legislation he supports, but the Senate is not in session if he wants to circumvent the advice and consent requirement of the Constitution,” McConnell said in a statement.

Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, said attending the arguments was like being a “kid in a candy store.”

“All three of the arguing counsel today had an enormously powerful command of the history of the exercise of the recess appointment power,” Lee said. “It was very interesting to hear how it had been viewed by the first few presidents, how it’s been exercised over the 225 years or so since the Constitution’s been in effect.”

Lee was optimistic about the chances for victory, suggesting the possibility of a unanimous decision backing the brief pro forma sessions, with closer rulings on other key questions.

During the argument, Justice Sonia Sotomayor elicited laughter for musing about the Senate’s work schedule.

“The Senate could choose, if it wanted to, and I think there might be some citizens that would encourage it to, to never recess,” Sotomayor said. “And to work every day, which … lots of people do.”

Humberto Sanchez contributed to this report.

Comments (23)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

author email

  1. Liberalism is Nonsense

    Jan. 14, 2014
    11:43 p.m.

    Since morality underpins liberty, we should remember that taking advantage of liberty’s opportunities obligates us to deal with resulting consequences.

  2. Socialism is Organized Evil

    Jan. 16, 2014
    4:48 a.m.

    While democratic processes attach value to each person, collectivism reduces each person to a vessel for the will of pernicious quacks.

  3. Anonymous

    July 25, 2015
    6:54 a.m.

    Very interesting subject, regards for putting up. “Experience a comb life gives you after you lose your hair.” by Judith Stern.

    http://www.sdorttuiiplmnr.com/

  4. Anonymous

    July 30, 2015
    6:39 p.m.

    Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this website. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal. I must say you have done a great job with this. Additionally, the blog loads super quick for me on Chrome. Exceptional Blog!

    http://brookereviews.com/product/children-learning-reading-program-jim-yang-review-legit-scam/

  5. Anonymous

    July 31, 2015
    1:34 p.m.

    I have been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this website. Studying this information So i?¦m happy to show that I’ve an incredibly just right uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to don?¦t forget this website and provides it a glance on a relentless basis.

    http://przedszkole-roza.pl/

  6. Anonymous

    Aug. 2, 2015
    6:32 p.m.

    I beloved as much as you’ll obtain carried out right here. The cartoon is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. nevertheless, you command get got an shakiness over that you would like be handing over the following. unwell indisputably come more beforehand once more since exactly the same just about very steadily inside of case you protect this increase.

    http://www.consultdustry.com/vacancies/

  7. Anonymous

    Aug. 6, 2015
    10:33 a.m.

    Great work! This is the type of information that should be shared around the internet. Shame on the search engines for not positioning this post higher! Come on over and visit my site . Thanks =)

    http://quotesautoinsurance.org/compare-auto-insurance-rates-by-zip-code.html

  8. Anonymous

    Aug. 7, 2015
    4:58 a.m.

    Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an very long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyhow, just wanted to say fantastic blog!

    http://topcheapinsurance.com

  9. Anonymous

    Aug. 7, 2015
    8:28 a.m.

    Some truly prime posts on this website , saved to my bookmarks.

    http://quotesautoinsurance.org/compare-auto-insurance-rates-by-zip-code.html

  10. Anonymous

    Aug. 9, 2015
    6:44 p.m.

    Fascinating blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A theme like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog stand out. Please let me know where you got your design. With thanks

    http://eblogtip.com/clickbank-university-review-cb-university-justin-allen-adam-horwitz-and-matt-hulett-8-things-you-should-know/

  11. Anonymous

    Aug. 9, 2015
    7:03 p.m.

    Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Thank you!

    http://eblogtip.com/get-paid-taking-pictures-review-michael-davis-9-things-you-should-know

  12. Anonymous

    Aug. 17, 2015
    11:37 p.m.

    What’s Going down i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It positively helpful and it has aided me out loads. I’m hoping to give a contribution & assist other users like its helped me. Great job.

    http://johnnylawrence.npage.de/

  13. Anonymous

    Aug. 19, 2015
    10:13 a.m.

    Hi there, I discovered your web site via Google while looking for a comparable subject, your site came up, it appears good. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    http://www.blogster.com/lettersfromsantaclaus/

  14. Anonymous

    Aug. 19, 2015
    10:21 a.m.

    Magnificent website. Lots of helpful information here. I am sending it to a few friends ans additionally sharing in delicious. And obviously, thanks on your sweat!

    http://lettersuktosanta.angelfire.com/write-a-letter-to-santa.html

  15. Anonymous

    Aug. 24, 2015
    12:25 p.m.

    As a Newbie, I am permanently searching online for articles that can be of assistance to me. Thank you

    http://quotesautoinsurance.org/primerica-insurance.html

  16. Anonymous

    Aug. 24, 2015
    12:42 p.m.

    I beloved as much as you’ll receive performed right here. The caricature is attractive, your authored material stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an nervousness over that you wish be delivering the following. sick certainly come further beforehand once more since exactly the similar nearly a lot continuously inside case you shield this increase.

    http://quotesautoinsurance.org/primerica-insurance.html

  17. Anonymous

    Aug. 25, 2015
    2:22 p.m.

    I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.

    http://meble-gabinetowe.uchwycone-chwile.pl/files/2015/08/stylowe-meble-okazja-300×197.png

  18. Anonymous

    Aug. 25, 2015
    4:37 p.m.

    Hi! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could locate a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one? Thanks a lot!

    http://mytechsocialbookmarking.asia/story.php?title=httpelfisanta-fr-7#discuss

  19. Anonymous

    Aug. 25, 2015
    11:36 p.m.

    Well I sincerely enjoyed studying it. This tip provided by you is very useful for accurate planning.

    http://topcheapinsurance.com/travelers-home-and-auto-insurance.html

  20. Anonymous

    Aug. 26, 2015
    4:49 a.m.

    I and also my guys came checking the great suggestions located on the blog and so all of a sudden came up with an awful feeling I never thanked the blog owner for those techniques. Those young boys were definitely for that reason passionate to study all of them and have undoubtedly been making the most of those things. Thanks for indeed being considerably accommodating and also for figuring out this form of good topics millions of individuals are really needing to know about. My very own honest regret for not saying thanks to sooner.

    http://topcheapinsurance.com/travelers-home-and-auto-insurance.html

  21. Anonymous

    Aug. 29, 2015
    11:40 p.m.

    You are a very capable person!

    http://scriptogr.am/yew70claus

  22. Anonymous

    Sept. 1, 2015
    10:30 p.m.

    Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research on this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such wonderful info being shared freely out there.

    http://executive-condo.com/the-criterion-ec-yishun/

Sign In

Forgot password?

Or

Subscribe

Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...